HAL Id: hal-02319357
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02319357
Submitted on 17 Oct 2019
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entic research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diusion de documents
scientiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Une réponse sociologique relative à la haute prévalence
du VIH auprès des personnes transgenre MtF provenant
d’Amérique latine
Olga L Gonzalez
To cite this version:
Olga L Gonzalez. Une réponse sociologique relative à la haute prévalence du VIH auprès des personnes
transgenre MtF provenant d’Amérique latine. Journée Scientique Sidaction 2019, Feb 2019, Paris,
France. 2008, �10.1007/s10461-007-9299-3�. �hal-02319357�
!"#$%&%'()*$"+*,%-(./+01+%+)%2(.3("(#3+,%41536%7892%4:9%;<=>%
%4)3?+163/@%A$136%-3B+1(/%%C%%("#$"0DE1++FE1%%%
!"#$%&'()(*
+,)*-. #$,() *($/0$1$2034)*5*16*&64%)*#-.761) ,/)*84*
9:!*64#-'(*8)(*;)<<)(*%-6,(*8=><.-034)*16?,)%
&+6%%E+55+6%/1$)6%"$G)(,%HI&,%()/%0)+%/1J6%E(1/+%K1@?$"+).+%B0%LMN%O%B$)6%P0$/1+%K$Q6%BR3553#1$G()%
SH1$).+,%M/$"3+,%T6K$#)+,%T/$/6C4)36U,%+""+6%()/%0)+%K1@?$"+).+%60K@13+01+%V%WXY%K(01%"$%/(/$"3/@%B+6%
@/0B+6%+Z$53)@+6,%$""$)/%[06P0RV%\<Y%B$)6%0)+%$66(.3$G()%K$1363+))+,%$?+.%0)+%5(Q+))+%)()%K()B@1@+%
B+%=;YF%7+6%)3?+$0Z%6()/%]+$0.(0K%K"06%@"+?@6%P0+%"+6%/$0Z%)$G()$0Z%S+)%H1$).+,%^,>Y%_%+)%T6K$#)+,%
^,=YUF%
%
&$%1+.`+1.`+%+Z$53)+%"+6%E$./+016%+ZK"3.$GE6%603?$)/6%%O%
WU%&+%/1$?$3"%B0%6+Z+%%%%<U%&+%)3?+$0%BR+ZK(63G()%$0%LMN%B$)6%"+%K$Q6%BR(13#3)+%aU%&R$KK$1/+)$).+%V%0)+%
53)(13/@%"3)#036GP0+%(0%.0"/01+""+%%%%%=U%&$%.()B3G() %/1$)6#+)1+%%
&$%1+.`+1.`+%+ZK"(1+%@#$"+5+)/%BR$0/1+6%`QK(/`J6+6,%+/%+)%K$1G.0"3+1,%"+%1b"+%B)(*,$-<)(*8)*2),-)*B+6%
53"3+0Z%BR(13#3)+%B+6%K+16())+6%S`@/@1(6+Z365+,%`(5(K`(]3+UF%%
9@?363(),%.(5K3"$G()%+/%$)$"Q6+%B+%"$%"3c@1$/01+%6.3+)GdP0+%S@K3B@53("(#3+,%6.3+).+6%6(.3$"+6U%+/%B +%"$%"3 c@1$/01+%
#136+%S1$KK(1/6%BR+ZK+1G6+,%1$KK(1/6%BR$66(.3$G()6UF%%
%
T)P0e/+%6(.3(C+/`)(#1$K`3P0+%1@$"36@+%$0K1J6%B+%E+55+6%/1$)6%BRf5@13P0+%"$G)+F%&+%/1$?$3"%B+%/+11$3)%P0$"3/$GE%
S(]6+1?$G()%K$1G.3K$)/+%+/%1@$"36$G()%Bg+)/1+G+)6%6+53CB313#@6%$?+.%"+6%K+16())+6%/1$)6%+/%"+%K+16())+"%5@B3.$"%
+/%$66(.3$GEU%$%@/@%1@$"36@%B$)6%"+6%?3""+6%B+%A$136,%:$B13B%+/%60]63B3$31+5+)/,%h$1.+"()+,%h(#(/i,%:3$53%+/%
I(1()/(F%%
%
f)$"Q6+6%B+%B())@+6%P0$)G/$G?+6%SB@K(03""+5+)/%B+%]$6+6%B+%B())@+6%V%K$1G1%B0%/1$?$3"%B+%1@.("/+%B+%B())@+6%B+%
B+0Z%$66(.3$G()6%K$1363+))+6%+/%BR0)+%$66(.3$G()%5$B13"J)+UF%%
@.(41%6%(*
AB*C)*%-67601*84*()D)E*%-'(*; - . 34) ,%*7$0-)*346(0*)D/14(0;*8)*/)F)*#$#416?$,*),*(0%46?$,*
8=.<02-6?$,E*,)* / $,(?%4)*#6(*4,)*76-06G1)*)D#10/6?7)*#6-*-6##$-%*64*-0(34)*8)*9:!B%
*%
T)%T6K$#)+,%"+6%E+55+6%"$G)(C$5@13.$3)+6%P03%+Z+1.+)/%"$%K1(6G/0G()%()/%0)+%K1@?$"+).+%B+%
<Y%SH(".`%+/%$",%<^W<U,%/$)B36%P0R+""+%+6/%B+%Wj,=Y%.`+*%"+6%E+55+6%/1$)6%P03%+Z+1.+)/%"$%
K1(6G/0G()F%-$)6%"+6%K$Q6%BR(13#3)+,%"$%K1@?$"+).+%B+%LMN%.`+*%"+6%E+55+6%/1$)6%+)%63/0$G()%B+%
K1(6G/0G()%+6/%B+%"R(1B1+%B+%<^Y,%$"(16%P0R+""+%+6/%3)E@13+01+%V%aY%K(01%"+6%E+55+6%.36#+)1+%
S)()%/1$)6U%+)%63/0$G()%B+%K1(6G/0G()%S4)$3B6,% <^W;UF%
HB*C6*/$,80?$,**%-6,(*,=)(%*#6(E*),*($0E*4,*;6/%) 4- *8) *- 0(34)*64*9:!B*C)*,07)64*8)*#-.761),/)*)(%*%-'(*
76-06G1)*),*;$,/?$,*84*2),-)B%
*%
T)%H1$).+,%BR$K1J6%"R+)P0e/+%M)6+15%B+%<^W^,%"$%K1@?$"+).+%B0%LMN%@/$3/%B+%jY%.`+*%"+6%/1$)6%:/H%P03%$?$3+)/%
1@$"36@%0)%/+6/%+/%B+%^%Y%.`+*%"+6%/1$)6%H/:%S'3$53%+/%$",%<^WWUF%
f0Z%T/$/6C4)36,%+)/1+%<^^\%+/%<^W=,%.`+*%"+6%<%a>W%K+16())+66%/1$)6%B3$#)(6GP0@+6%6@1(K(63G?+6,%;=Y%
@/$3+)/%B+6%/1$)6%:/H%+/%W>Y%@/$3+)/%B+6%/1$)6%H/:F%S7+)/+16%E(1%-+6+$6+%7()/1("%$)B%A1+?+)G(),%<^WjUF% %
%
IB*J6,(*1)(*#6"(*8=0<<02-6?$,E**1)(*%-6,(*K%L*8)(*<0,$-0%.(*/41%4-)11)(*$4**10,240(?34)(*$,%*1)(*
#14(*;$-%(*,07)64D* 8=0,/ 08),/)*8)*9:!%%
%%
!
%%
%
%
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
MB*C)*%64D*8)*#-.761),/)*84*9:!*8)(*;)<<)(*%-6,(*)(%*%-'(*.1)7.*),*><.-034)*16?,)%
*%
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
%
%
%%%%
%
%
%
NO*C=),34P%)*(=)(%*#),/&.) *(4- *1) (*%- 6Q)/%$0-)(*R#6-/$4-(*8)*70)O*08),?%60-)(*)%*< 02-6%$0-)(*8)(*#)-($,,)(*S***
%
• &+6%E$./+016%6(.3$0Z%+/%.0"/01+"6%B0%53"3+0%BR(13#3)+%6()/%B@/+153)$)/6%K(01%.(5K1+)B1+%"+6%K$1.(0 16%B+%?3+F%%
• &+6%)(15+6%B+%#+)1+,%13#3B+6,%B+6%53"3+0Z%B+%6(.3$"36$G()%BR(13#3)+%S`@/@1(6+Z365+%+/%`(5(K`(]3+U%+ZK"3P0+)/% B$)6% 0)+%
#1$)B+%5+601+%"+6%.`+53)+5+)/6%3B+)G/$31+6%+/%"+6%.()B3G()6%B+%?3+%5$1#3)$"+6%+/%"+6%?0")@1$]3"3/@6%B+6%/1$)6%:/H%K$1%
1$KK(1/%$0%LMNF%
• &+6%?3("+).+6%6()/%6/10./01+""+6%B$)6%"+6%/1$[+./(31+6%B+%?3+%B+6%K+16())+6%_%+""+6%K+15+c+)/%$0663%B+%.(5K1+)B1+%"+6%
?0")@1$]3"3/@6%B+6%K+16())+6%/1$)6#+)1+6%K$1%1$KK(1/%$0%LMNF%%
• &+6%K1([+/6%BR@53#1$G()%6()/%/1J6%K1@6+)/6%B$)6%"+%53"3+0,%+/%0)+%.(5K(6$)/+%.+)/1$"+%+)%+6/%"$%K1(6G/0G()F%%
• &$%K1(6G/0G()%)+%6+%"353/+%K$6%V%0)+%3)6+1G()%B$)6%"$%d" 3J1+%K1(E+663()) +""+%B 0%/1$?$3"%B 0%6+Z+%_%.R+6/%$0663%0) +%
k%.(550)$0/@%B+%B+6G)%lF%%
• &$%1+.`+1.`+%$%B@?+"(KK@%"$%)(G()%BR%k%3)@"0./$]3"3/@%B+%"R3)E+.G()%l%K( 01%1+)B1+%.(5K/+%B+%"$%]$) $"3 /@%B0%L MN%B$)6 %0)%
53"3+0%(m%"+6%?3("+).+6%+/%"+6%B36.1353)$G()6%6R3)6.13?+)/%B$)6%"+6%K $1.(016%B+%?3+F%%
%
201%0)%K"$)%K"06%(K@1$G())+",%0)%1@60"/$/%60KK" @5+)/$31+%B+%"R+)P0e/+%+6/%"$%
536+%+)%K"$.+%B0%@.()64*:,%)-,6?$,61*:,%)-80(/0#10,60-)*8)*T&)-/&)4-(*)%*
U-$;)((0$,,)1(*%-6760116,%*67)/*1)(*16?,$V6<.-0/60,(*)%*1)*9:!%O%
"$G)(6?3`F`QK(/`+6+6F(1#%
%%
4)%B+6%(][+.GE6%B0%9@6+$0%+6/%"R@.`$)#+%B+%.())$366$).+6%1+"$G?+6%V%"$%K136+%
+)%.`$1#+%5@B3.$"+%+/%6(.3$"+%B+%.+c+%K(K0"$G(),%"$%.())$366$).+%B+6%
B3n@1+)/+6%K("3GP0+6%K0]"3P0+6%+/%K1$GP0+6%$66(.3$G?+6,%"$%536+%+)%.(550)%
B+%/1$?$0Z%6.3+)GdP0+6,%$3)63%P0+%"$%E(150"$G()%B+%K1([+/6F%%
%
f%.+%[(01,%"+%9@6+$0%1+#1(0K+%K"06%BR0)+%.+)/$3)+%B+%5+5]1+6F%2RQ%
1+/1(0?+)/%B+6%.`+1.`+016%B+%B3n@1+)/+6%B36.3K"3)+6%O%6.3+).+6%6(.3$"+6,%
5@B+.3)+,%6$)/@%K0]"3P0+,%@K3B@53("(#3+,%$3)63%P0+%B+6%K1$G.3+)6%/1$?$3""$)/%
B$)6%B+6%!8',%$66(.3$G()6,%E()B$G()6%+/%3)6G/0G()6%K0]" 3P0 +6%S53) 36/J1+,%
."3)3P0+6U,%+/%B+6%K1(E+663())+"6%/1$?$3""$)/%$?+.%"+6%K+16())+6%/1$)6%"$G)(C
$5@13.$3)+6%+)%f5@13P0+%"$G)+,%f5@13P0+%B0%8(1B%+/%+)%T01(K+F%%
%
U)-(#)/?7)(*
K.%&$8)(*
"#$%&'$(!)*'+,#-./$&-!)&!012!34&5!6&-!78',-!
!97:!'$(!;<=!&7!*>?'37!)&!6'!@8'3&AB!CDDEFCDGH%
%2(01.+O%7-7A,%<^Wj%
I'$(!)&!012!34&5!6&-!78',-!97:!&,!:8',3&!JCDGDK%
2(01.+%O%'3$53%+/%$",%<^WW%%
I'$(!)&!?8L%'6&,3&!)&!012!34&5!6&-!?#?$6'.#,-!36L-!&,!=>L8*/$&!6'.,&!JCDGM!N!CDGOK%
2(01.+%O%P6#Q'6!=*)-!9#,*7#8*,+,%!)063B$,%<^W;%
U)-(#)/?7)(S*
%
&$%.(5K"+Z3/@%B+6%/1$[+./(31+6%B+%?3+%B+6%K+16())+6%P03%E()/%"R(][+/%B+%.+c+%@/0B+%5()/1+%"$%B3o.0"/@%BR$?(31%
0)+%K("3GP0+%B+%K1@?+)G()%B0%LMN%+/%B+6%M2I%1@+""+5+)/%+o.$.+F%&+6%E$./+016%6/10./01+"6,%.(55+%
"R`(5(K`(]3+%(0%"R`@/@1(6+Z365+%B$)6%"+6%53"3+0Z%BR(13#3)+%6()/%`(16%B +%"$%K( 1/@+%B+6%K("3GP 0+6%B+%
K1@?+)G()%K()./0+""+6%1@$"36@+6%B$)6%"+6%K$Q6%BR3553#1$G()F%4)+%6/1$/@#3+%50"GB35+)63())+""+%+/%
3)/+1B36.3K"3)$31+%B$)6%"+6%K$Q6%BR(13#3)+%+/%BR$..0+3",%B(0]"@+%BR0)+%?(" ()/@%K( "3 GP0 +%E(1/+,%6+1$3/%+)%+n+/%
)@.+66$31+F%
%%
-$)6%"+6%K$Q6%BR3553#1$G()%601%"+6P0+"6%$%K(1/@%"R+)P0e/+,%3"%Q%$%.+1/$3)+6%.()6/$)/+6%S.(55+%"$%E(1/+%
3)6+1G()%B$)6%"+%/1$?$3"%B0%6+Z+UF%M"%Q%$%$0663%B+6%B3n@1+).+6,%K$1%+Z+5K"+%1+"$G?+6%$0Z%)3?+$0Z%BR3)/@#1$G()%
B$)6%"$%6(.3@/@%S.()/$./6%$?+.%"$%K(K0"$G()%"(.$"+,%1+66+)G%1+"$GE%V%"$%6("3/0 B+U%(0 %V%"$%K $1G.3K$G( )%V%
"R+)?31())+5+)/%$66(.3$GEF%%
%%
7+c+%1+.`+1.`+%3)?3/+%V%K(01603?1+%"R+Z$5+)%B+6%B3n@1+).+6%(]6+1?@+6%B$)6%"+6%K$Q6%BR3553#1$G()%+/%@?$"0+1%
"+%"3+)%$?+.%"R%k%3)@"0./$]3"3/@%B0%LMN%lF%M"%+6/%)@.+66$31+%B+%.(5K$1+1%"+6%B3n@1+)/+6%E(15+6%B+%/1$?$3"%B+6%
3)6G/0G()6%+/%$66(.3$G()6%/1$?$3""$)/%$?+.%"+6%HI&%+/%.()/1$6/+1%.+6%+ZK@13+).+6F%%
%%
-0%K(3)/%B+%?0+%B+6%K1$GP0+6%3)6G/0G())+""+6%(0%$66(.3 $G?+6,%3"%Q%$%0)+%/+)63 ()% O%E$0/C3 ",%(03 %() %)() ,%6+%
E(.$"36+1%601%"+6%6K@.3d.3/@6%B+%.+c+%K(K0"$G(),%+/%K1(K(6+1%B+6%K1(#1$55+6%P03%"+01%6()/%+Z."063?+5+)/%
B@B3@6%p%-$)6%P0+""+%5+601+%.+"$%K+0/%.()/13]0+1%$0%1+K"3,%V%"R36("+5+)/%+/%V%"R3B@+%B+%"R%k%3)@"0./$]3 "3 /@%B0%
LMN%lp%%%
@.;.-),/)(*
U4G10/6?$,(*8)*1=64%)4-*340*8.7)1$##),%*8)(*6(#)/%(*/0%.(*S%
'()*i"+*,%!"#$%&F,%7((1B3)$G()%6.3+)GdP0+%S$?+.%7136G)$%q0+?+B(U%
B+%"$%R#6&.,'!"S!T,%A0]"3.$G()%B+%"$%H$.0"/$B%B+%73+).3$6%N05$)$6%
B+%"$%4)3?+163B$B%8$.3()$"%B+%7("(5]3$,%601%"+%/`J5+%k%'@)+1(%Q%
6$"0B%6+Z0$"%Q%1+K1(B0.G?$%l,%<^W\%
'()*i"+*,%!"#$%&F,%k%&R35]13.$G()%."$66+%+/%6+Z+%V%"Rr0?1+%O%K$1.(016%
3B+)G/$31+6%+/%53#1$/(31+6%.`+*%"+6%K+16())+6%/1$)6%:/H%"$G)(C
$5@13.$3)+6%l,%1+?0+%'+)1+,%6+Z0$"3/@%+/%6(.3@/@%8s<^,%<^W\%
'()*i"+*,%!"#$%&F,t&$%K("uG.$%&'hI%Q%+"%1+/(%E1+)/+%$"%LMNv63B$w,%3)%
-3+*,%9+?36/$%f1.$B3$,%<^W;%
%
W-6764D*/0%.(S%%
7+)/+16%E(1%-+6+$6+%7()/1("%$)B%A1+?+)G(),%7-7A,%tNML%f5()#%
N36K$)3.6v&$G)(6w,%$?13"%<^Wj%
T).0+6/$%8$.3()$"%2(]1+%-36.1353)$.3()%B+%A+16()$6%I1$)6#@)+1(6,%
M)[06G.3$%$%.$B$%K$6(O%0)%?36/$*(%$%"$G)D6%+).0+6/$BD6%+)%"$%
T).0+6/$%8$.3()$"%6(]1+%-36.1353)$.3()%B+%A+16()$6%I1$)#@)+1(6%
S8I-2U,%<^^;%
H+1)i)B+*C-i?3"$%+/%$",%tf"/$%K1+?$"+).3$%B+"%?3`%Q%.()B0./$6%6+Z0$"+6%
B+%13+6#(%+)%50[+1+6%/1$)6+Z0$"+6%/1$]$[$B(1$6%6+Z0$"+6%B+%
h$1.+"()$w,%2/(K%23B$,%h$1.+"()$,%<^WWF%
H(".`%73)/$%+/%$",%%xI+)B+).3$6%B+%"$%K1+?$"+).3$%B+"%LMN%Q%B+%"$6%
.()B0./$6%B+%13+6#(%$6(.3$B$6%+)%50[+1+6%/1$]$[$B(1$6%B+"%6+Z(%+)%
7$/$"0y$x,%P'3&7'!<',*7'8*'%<^W=_%<;%SaU,%KF%W\Xz<^<%
'$""3%:,%&7!'6U%tNMLCW%3)E+.G(),%/0]+1.0"(636,%$)B%6QK`3"36%3)%5$"+%
/1$)66+Z0$"%K1(6G/0/+6%3)%:3"$),%M/$"QwF%V#$8,'6!#W!'3/$*8&)!*>>$,&!
)&X3*&,3Y!-Y,)8#>&-,%W\\W_%=O%W^^XCjF%
'3$53,%f"$3),%+/%$",%k%7$1$./@136GP0+6%6(.3(CB@5(#1$K`3P0+6,%
3B+)Gd.$G()6%B+%#+)1+,%K$1.(016%B+%/1$)63G()%5@B3.(C
K6Q.`("(#3P0+6%+/%LMNv63B$%B$)6%"$%K(K0"$G()%/1$)6F%A1+53+16%
1@60"/$/6%BR0)+%+)P0e/+%5+)@+%+)%H1$).+,%<^W^%lF%R$66&.,!
Z?*)L>*#6#+*/$&!2&Q)#>')'*8&!S=<U,%=aaC=aj,%<^WW%
'3",%H1$){(36+%+/%$",%t-36.1353)$G()6%+/%6G#5$G6$G()%BR0)+%
K(K0"$G()O%"+%.$6%B+6%E+55+6%/1$)6R%53#1$)/+6w,%[8#+8'>>&!)&!
-#$.&,!&,!W'%&$8!)&!6'!6$\&!3#,78&!6&-!)*-38*>*,'.#,-!&,!16&F)&F
:8',3&,%E@?13+1%<^W=%
N+1]6/,%NF,%+/%$",%xT6G5$G)#%NML%A1+?$"+).+%$)B%936|%h+`$?3(16%(E%
I1$)6#+)B+1%A+16()6%3)%/`+%4)3/+B%2/$/+6O%f%2Q6/+5$G.%9+?3+}x,%
fM-2%h+`$?%S<^^;U%W<OWzWj,%-!M%W^FW^^jv6W^=XWC^^jC\<\\Ca%
!)063B$%-fIf,%P6#Q'6!=*)-!9#,*7#8*,+,%<^W;F%
• &+6% 6+0"6% E$./+016% B+% "R3)6+1G()%
B$)6% "+% /1$?$3"% B0% 6+Z+,% "$% .()B3G()%
/1$)6,% (0% "R3553#1$G()% )R+ZK"3P0+)/%
K$6% "+6% )3?+$0Z% /1J6% @"+?@6% B+% L MNF%
&+6% ) 3?+$0Z% B+% K1@?$"+).+% 6()/% /1J6%
@"+?@6%B$)6%" +6%K$Q6%BR(13#3)+%+/%B$)6 %
"+6% K$Q6% BR$..0+3"F% &+6% B())@+6%
+5K313P0+6% 3)B3P0+)/% P0+% .R+6/% "+01%
K(63G()% B$)6% B+6% 6(.3@/@6% `@/@1(C
6+Z36/+6% P03% 1+)B% .(5K/+% B+% "+01%
?0")@1$]3"3/@%$0%LMNF%
%
• &+6%/1$[+./(31+6%B$)6%"+%#+)1+%B+6%
HI&% )+% 6+% " 353 /+)/% K$6% $0% 5(5+)/%
K()./0+"% B+% "$% /1$)63B+)G/@F% T""+6%
6R3)6.13?+)/% B$)6% 0)% K1(.+6606% B+%
"()#0+% B01@+F% &+6% )(15+6% `@/@1(C
6+Z36/+6% B0% 53"3+0% BR(13#3)+% B@/+1C
53)+)/% "+6% K$1.(016F% &$% ?3("+).+,% "$%
K1@.$13/@% +/% "+% 6G#5$/+% Q% 6()/% /1J6%
K1@6+)/ 6% _% B$)6% .+% .()/+Z/+,% "$%
P0+6G()%B0%LMN%+6/%6+.()B$31+%K(01%
"+6% K+16())+6% Sk% 3)@"0./$]3"3/@% B+%
"R3)E+.G()%lUF%
T$,/14(0$,(*%